Annville and Palmyra each have a North Railroad Street. In the second half of September, 39 North Railroad Street in Annville Township transferred for $240,000. In the same two weeks, 749 North Railroad Street in Palmyra Borough transferred for $339,900. Both towns are in Lebanon County, and on the same street name the difference was close to $100,000.
That pair matches what most buyers already assume, that Annville is the less expensive version of Palmyra. The deed records from September and October 2026 support that assumption for one kind of house only. On Annville's older streets the discount holds. In South Annville's new subdivisions, homes are closing at prices above most of the older homes in Palmyra Borough. A buyer comparing the two towns is really choosing between an older house and a new one, and that choice moves the price more than the town line does.
The figures below come from LebTown's twice-monthly Lebanon County real estate transfer lists covering Sept. 1 through Oct. 31, 2026. Annville, South Annville, Palmyra and North Londonderry are all in Lebanon County, so all four appear in the same public record. Transfers recorded for $1, along with estate and sheriff transfers, are left out because they don't reflect what a buyer would pay. Every other figure is the price recorded on the deed.
The Older Streets: About $70,000 Apart
Between Sept. 1 and Oct. 31, 2026, Annville Township recorded priced transfers on Maple, Cherry, Railroad, Lancaster, Queen, Walnut and Main streets. Most landed between $180,000 and $320,000:
| Annville Township address | Recorded price | Window |
|---|---|---|
| 337 East Maple Street | $195,000 | Sept. 1–15 |
| 1331 East Walnut Street | $295,000 | Sept. 1–15 |
| 143 Woodside Court | $310,000 | Sept. 1–15 |
| 819 Maple Street | $210,000 | Sept. 16–30 |
| 107 North Cherry Street | $226,000 | Sept. 16–30 |
| 503 West Main Street | $211,000 | Sept. 16–30 |
| 245 North Lancaster Street | $236,000 | Sept. 16–30 |
| 935 East Queen Street | $317,000 | Sept. 16–30 |
| 124 South Spruce Street | $369,000 | Sept. 16–30 |
| 217 South Cherry Street | $180,000 | Oct. 1–15 |
| 136 North Railroad Street | $190,000 | Oct. 1–15 |
| 610 East Walnut Street | $420,000 | Oct. 1–15 |
| 330 East Main Street | $560,000 | Oct. 1–15 |
Counted with 39 North Railroad Street, the midpoint of those fourteen transfers sits near $238,000.
Palmyra Borough's older streets recorded a higher and tighter range over the same two months. 419 South Harrison Street went for $245,000, 331 North College Street for $262,500, 832 West Maple Street for $250,000 and 225 East Broad Street for $275,000. At the upper end, 201 South Railroad Street recorded $360,000 and 716 West Maple Street $395,000. Across a dozen single-address borough transfers, the midpoint lands near $308,000.
On older housing, then, the September and October 2026 difference between the two towns was roughly $70,000. That is a real discount, but it is narrower than the gap between town-wide medians that circulates online. Those medians blend Palmyra's newer subdivisions into its number. Annville's in-town figure is mostly older homes, and the comparison tilts as a result.
The ranges also overlap. A buyer with a $250,000 to $320,000 budget had recorded options in both towns this fall, from East Walnut and East Queen in Annville to South Harrison and West Main in Palmyra. The two price ranges aren't separate.
South Annville's New Construction Closes at Palmyra Prices
South Annville is where the comparison shifts. On Oct. 16 through 31, Garman Builders at Wynfield recorded the sale of 180 Bellflower Avenue, Lot 57, for $638,806. Wynfield at Annville is an age-qualified 55+ community. In late September, 139 Alexandria Drive, Lot 34 in Southgate, recorded at $640,990. Both prices are higher than every older-street transfer in Palmyra Borough over the same two months.
Two Southgate lots, 108 and 143 Alexandria Drive, also transferred from the developer, South Annville Holdings, for $160,000 each in early September. Those were land sales. They give a rough sense of what the lot alone costs before a house goes on it in that subdivision.
Townhomes cover the next tier down. At Candler's Pointe, 109 Candler Way recorded at $395,006 and 100 Candler Way at $395,883. Both closed above the Palmyra Borough midpoint, and both are newer than almost anything in the borough's older core.
Resales inside South Annville's newer neighborhoods fall between those tiers. Two Mayapple Woods units, 239 Highland Court and 79 Beech Tree Court, recorded at $340,000 and $320,000 in early September, and 14 Finch Drive in Olde South Crossing recorded at $495,000. In late October, 1446 South White Oak Street recorded at $399,000. A Mayapple Woods unit at $320,000 to $340,000 is priced against Palmyra's older single-family homes. Buyers deciding between the two are choosing the age of the house as much as the town.
Where Palmyra Still Costs More
The clearest remaining gap is between new construction in the two areas. North of Palmyra in North Londonderry Township, Summer Layne by Landmark Homes recorded 600 Sunset Boulevard at $694,200 and 805 Sunset Boulevard at $820,293 in the second half of October. Winding Creek, Landmark's age-qualified 55+ community, recorded units between $449,800 and $635,114 across September and October. Edgemont Preserve recorded 44 Canterbury Lane at $409,300.
Southgate's $640,990 sits roughly $53,000 to $179,000 below Summer Layne's two October closings. The two 55+ communities are closer, with Wynfield's $638,806 near the top of Winding Creek's recorded range. Inside Palmyra Borough, the Melrose development recorded 922 North Lincoln Street at $579,896 and a duplex lot at 942 North Lincoln Street at $462,816. Orchard Hill Estates recorded 685 East Spruce Street at $530,000.
North Londonderry's older subdivisions sit much closer to Annville's newer ones. 5 Dianna Drive in Old Forge Acres recorded at $378,000, 23 Eisenhower Road at $310,000 and 18 Lynnwood Drive in Londonderry Farms at $339,000. A buyer who wants a postwar subdivision home on the Palmyra side can spend roughly what a Mayapple Woods unit or a South White Oak Street home costs in South Annville.
The County Numbers Behind This Fall's Prices
Bright MLS's October 2026 report for Central Pennsylvania, with data as of Nov. 6, puts Lebanon County's median sold price at $337,777 for the month. That is up 16.5% from October 2025, on 142 closed sales. A 16.5% jump in one year is far more than the region's 3.3% October gain. It is consistent with more new construction in the month's sales, including the Wynfield, Southgate and Summer Layne closings above.
The same October report shows Lebanon County buyers had more room than a year earlier. Median days on market reached 22, up 14 days from October 2025, against 12 days for Central Pennsylvania overall. Active listings rose 19.5% to 447, and months of supply reached 3.54, above every county in the report except Schuylkill. New listings were up 25.0% from October 2025 while new purchase contracts were down 13.5%. More sellers listed in October 2026 and fewer buyers signed contracts, so a buyer had more choice and more time on either side of the township line.
What South Annville Has Approved Next
The South Annville supply that is pushing up the high end of Annville's range is set to grow. At their Sept. 9, 2026 meeting, South Annville Township supervisors unanimously approved final plans for Garman Builders' Wynfield at Annville phases 2a and 2b, totaling 27 and 17 single-family units, as LebTown reported. Work on both phases began this fall, and Garman Builders has had quick-move-in homes and buildable homesites available at Wynfield. The October closing at $638,806 is the most recent recorded price for a finished Wynfield home.
At the same meeting, supervisors approved a revised plan for DHL's Clear Springs Logistics Park, which included reducing the first building from 1.4 million to 1.22 million square feet and adding employee parking. For buyers who work in the township, that is a large employer site in the same township as Wynfield, Southgate and Candler's Pointe.
How to Compare the Two Towns
The comparison worth making is house to house. For an older home in town, Annville Township's recorded transfers this fall ran about $70,000 below Palmyra Borough's, with overlap from roughly $245,000 to $320,000. New single-family construction at Wynfield and Southgate in South Annville reached the $640,000 range, still below Summer Layne's October closings but above most of Palmyra Borough's older streets. For newer resales between $320,000 and $400,000, Mayapple Woods and Candler's Pointe in South Annville and Old Forge Acres and Londonderry Farms in North Londonderry were trading at similar prices.
Our earlier look at Palmyra's "hottest ZIP code" reputation traced how that market slowed in 2026, and our guide to choosing between new construction and historic homes in Annville covers the housing styles behind these price bands. For a three-way comparison closer to Hershey, see Hershey vs. Hummelstown vs. Palmyra.
If you own an older home on one of these streets and want to know where it falls among this fall's recorded transfers, Team Becker Realtors can compare your address with recent closings in your part of Annville or Palmyra. Start with a free home value estimate, or use our buyer's guide to start a street-by-street search in both towns.